;blackcat

Foreign Transaction Fee: FX Markups, DCC and Card Costs

A card payment in another currency can carry three separate costs, and only one of them is usually called a foreign transaction fee. The other two hide inside exchange rates: the rate the card network applies, and, if you accept the offer at the till, the rate a shop or ATM sets for you. Statements often show a single euro figure, so the split is easy to miss.

This guide takes one hypothetical purchase apart layer by layer, then covers online shopping, ATMs and the moment your rate is fixed. The figures are illustrations, not current tariffs.

Three costs, three owners

What is a foreign transaction fee? It is a charge your card issuer adds when a payment is in a currency other than your account currency, usually a percentage of the converted amount. Foreign transaction fees are set by the issuer and appear in its price list.

The foreign exchange markup is different. Card networks convert the merchant's currency into your billing currency at their own daily rate, which sits a little away from reference rates. That spread is not itemised anywhere; it is built into the converted amount.

Dynamic currency conversion is the third layer and the only optional one. A terminal or ATM offers to charge you in euros instead of the local currency. If you accept, the merchant's provider converts the amount at a rate it chooses, and the network and issuer conversion never happen.

The foreign transaction fee vs currency conversion fee question trips people up because some issuers use the second name for the first charge. Read the price list for what is charged, not what it is called. A card currency conversion fee and a foreign transaction fee are often the same line item under different labels.

One purchase, broken down

How are foreign transaction fees calculated? Take a hypothetical walker with a euro account who buys hiking boots priced at CZK 3,200 in a Prague outdoor shop. Assume a reference rate of CZK 25.00 per euro, a network rate of CZK 24.90, an issuer fee of 1.5%, and a DCC offer at CZK 23.75.

horizontal scroll
RouteCalculationCost in eurosMarkup over reference rate
Reference rate only (benchmark)3,200 ÷ 25.00€128.00–
Pay in koruna: network conversion3,200 ÷ 24.90€128.510.4%
Pay in koruna: plus 1.5% issuer fee€128.51 + €1.93€130.441.9%
Accept DCC at the terminal3,200 ÷ 23.75€134.745.3%

Hypothetical rates and fees showing how each conversion layer changes the euro cost of the same CZK 3,200 purchase.

Source: Illustrative calculation; disclosure rules from Regulation (EU) 2021/1230, EUR-Lex, 2021

Even with an issuer fee, paying in koruna costs €4.30 less than DCC in this example. The gap comes from the rate, not from any visible fee, which is why DCC vs card exchange rate is the comparison that matters at the till.

EU law makes that comparison easier for EU currencies. Under the cross-border payments regulation, card issuers and DCC providers must express their total conversion charges as a percentage markup over the latest euro reference rate from the European Central Bank, disclose it before you pay, and issuers must send you an electronic message with that markup after a card payment in another EU currency. The message rule does not cover payments in dollars, francs or pounds.

Should I pay in local currency abroad?

Should I pay in local currency abroad? In most cases, yes. When a terminal asks you to pay in local currency or home currency, choosing home currency activates DCC and hands the rate to the merchant's provider. Visa's guidance says the screen must show both amounts, the exchange rate and any markup, and recommends declining the offer if those details are missing or you feel pushed.

Before choosing, compare two numbers: the markup over the ECB rate shown on the screen, and your issuer's published markup for that currency. The lower one wins. DCC sometimes appears with a "guaranteed rate" label; the guarantee is real, and so is the price of it.

A hypothetical evening in Budapest shows the pressure point. An ATM offers to withdraw HUF 40,000 with "conversion to EUR at a guaranteed rate" and preselects that option. Pressing "decline conversion" keeps the withdrawal in forint, and the conversion follows your card's terms instead of the ATM operator's rate.

Online purchases and non-euro shops

Can online purchases have foreign transaction fees? Yes, and the location of the shop's payment processing matters as much as the price tag. A website can display euros while its acquirer sits outside the EEA, and some issuers treat that as a cross-border transaction. A site can also run DCC at checkout, offering to "charge in EUR" an item priced in dollars.

Consider a hypothetical designer in Vilnius buying a USD 49 font licence from a US foundry. The checkout offers €46.10 or USD 49. The euro option is the shop's own conversion. Paying in dollars lets the card network convert and the issuer apply its published terms, which is the only version she can check against a price list. These international card payment fees vary by issuer, so the comparison is worth thirty seconds.

ATM fees and when the rate is fixed

Are ATM fees separate from card conversion fees? Yes. A cash withdrawal abroad can carry an operator fee charged by the ATM owner, your issuer's withdrawal fee, and a conversion cost on top, plus DCC if you accept it. A card advertised with no foreign transaction fee can still meet all of these.

That answers a related question: does no foreign transaction fee mean no FX cost? No. The network's rate still applies, DCC can still be offered, and ATM operators still charge. The issuer's pricing for spending in other currencies is the place to check.

When is the card exchange rate fixed? With DCC, at the terminal, the moment you accept. When you pay in local currency, the network converts the amount when the transaction is processed, often a day or more after the purchase, using its rate for that processing date. That explains why the pending amount in your app can differ slightly from the final one, and why a refund weeks later can return a different euro figure than you paid.

Key takeaways

  • Three layers: issuer fee, network rate, and optional DCC.
  • In the worked example, DCC cost €4.30 more than paying in koruna with a 1.5% fee.
  • Compare markups over the ECB rate, not fee labels.
  • "No foreign transaction fee" does not mean no conversion cost.
  • Card-route rates are fixed at processing; DCC rates at the terminal.

Check the terms before you travel

Blackcat cards are linked to a euro payment account, so payments in other currencies are converted. See the current conditions for Blackcat euro payment cards and compare Blackcat card features on the pricing page.

FAQ

How does a foreign transaction fee differ from an exchange-rate markup?

The fee is a visible charge from your issuer. The markup is the spread built into the conversion rate, shown only as a percentage over a reference rate.

What is dynamic currency conversion at a shop or ATM?

An offer to be charged in your home currency, with the merchant's provider setting the rate. Accepting it replaces your card's own conversion.

What should you compare before choosing local or home currency?

The markup over the ECB rate shown on the screen against your issuer's published markup for that currency.

Can an online purchase from another country trigger extra charges?

Yes. A non-euro price, a merchant processed outside the EEA or a checkout conversion offer can all add costs.

Does a card with no foreign transaction fee guarantee free conversion?

No. The network rate, DCC offers and ATM operator fees can still apply.

Which ATM fees can be added to the card issuer's charges?

The operator's own withdrawal fee and, if you accept it, the ATM's currency conversion.

Where should Blackcat users check current card and currency-conversion terms?

On the Blackcat pricing page and the card conditions, which list current charges for payments and withdrawals in other currencies.

What is a foreign transaction fee?

A charge a card issuer adds to payments made in a currency other than the account currency.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal, tax or financial advice.
Blackcat is issued by Papaya, Ltd. Papaya, Ltd. is licensed by the Malta Financial Services Authority as an Electronic Money Institution (EMI). Registration number C55146. Client funds are safeguarded in accordance with applicable legislation. Funds held in e-money accounts are not covered by the Depositor Compensation Scheme.